Today's clue from the New York Times crossword puzzle is : 'When it's ___' (answer to an old riddle) First let's look and see if we can find any hints in the New York Times crossword puzzle. Then we will gather any relevent information we need in order to find the correct answer to the clue 'When it's ___' (answer to an old riddle) that has been given in the New York Times crossword puzzle. Finally we will list any possible answers here below for the clue 'When it's ___' (answer to an old riddle).